Premium Audits: What to Expect and How We Help

A premium audit is the insurance company’s year-end check of the numbers your policy was priced on. Your workers compensation, general liability and some commercial auto policies start with an estimate of payroll, sales or subcontractor costs. When the policy year ends, the carrier confirms the real figures and adjusts the premium up or down. Nearly every business with one of these policies is audited every year, and it is normal.

Karstens Financial handles the audit with you from the first notice to the final bill. This page explains what to expect, what records to gather, and what we do on your behalf.

How the audit works

  1. Your policy term ends. Within about 30 to 60 days the carrier (or an audit company working for them) sends an audit notice. Our office receives a copy too, and we add it to your file the same day.
  2. You gather the records. The notice says whether it is a mail-in or online self-audit, a phone audit, or an in-person audit. Our checklist below covers what every auditor asks for.
  3. The auditor works up the numbers. Payroll is sorted by class code, overtime premium pay and some other items are taken out, owners and officers are included or excluded per your policy, and uninsured subcontractors are added in.
  4. We review it before it is final. Karstens checks the auditor’s worksheet for class codes, excluded pay, officer treatment and subcontractor charges, and disputes anything that is wrong.
  5. The carrier bills or refunds the difference. If your actual figures were higher than the estimate, there is an additional premium; if lower, a return premium. We go over the result with you and set up payment if any is due.

Why it matters to respond on time

An audit that is not completed by the carrier’s deadline is not forgotten. The carrier will estimate your exposure, usually well above the original estimate, bill you for it, and can add a non-compliance charge, cancel the policy, or refuse to renew. An unfinished audit also makes it hard to place coverage with a new carrier. Sending records on time is almost always cheaper than ignoring the notice, even when the numbers went up.

Records checklist

Gather these for the policy period shown on your notice (not the calendar year). You usually do not need all of them; the auditor’s notice says which apply to you.

Payroll (workers comp and most GL)

  • Quarterly federal 941s and state unemployment (SUTA) reports for every quarter in the period
  • Payroll journal or summary by employee showing gross wages, with overtime shown separately
  • Each employee’s job duties and work location, so payroll lands in the right class code
  • Owners, partners and officers: names, titles, ownership percentage and pay
  • W-2s or year-end payroll summary if the period lines up with a calendar year

Subcontractors and outside labor

  • List of every subcontractor and 1099 worker paid during the period, with the amount paid and the type of work
  • A certificate of insurance from each one showing their own workers comp and general liability in force during the period
  • 1099s and the cash disbursements or general ledger detail behind them

Why the certificates matter: a subcontractor who cannot show their own coverage is treated as your employee, and what you paid them is charged to your policy as payroll. A $40,000 uninsured sub can add thousands to your audit.

Sales and operations (general liability)

  • Gross sales or receipts for the period, by location or type of work if you have more than one
  • Sales tax returns or a profit and loss statement for the period
  • A short description of what the business did during the year, including anything new (new services, new location, new equipment)

What Karstens does for you

  • We track the notice. Every audit notice on your account is logged in our service system with its due date, and your account manager follows it until it is closed.
  • We send you a records request and reminders. You will get an email and a text from our office with the checklist and the due date, and reminders before the deadline so nothing is estimated.
  • We prepare the records with you. Not sure which class code a job falls under, whether an owner is excluded, or how to show overtime? Send what you have and we sort it out before it goes to the auditor.
  • We chase subcontractor certificates. Give us the list and we will request certificates directly from your subs so you are not charged for them.
  • We review the auditor’s worksheet. Class codes, overtime excess, officer inclusion or exclusion, clerical and outside sales splits, and subcontractor charges are the usual places audits go wrong. We check each one and file a dispute with the carrier when the worksheet is off.
  • We handle the result. If there is an additional premium we explain it line by line, set up a payment plan when the carrier offers one, and apply any return premium. Then we correct next year’s estimate so the next audit is closer to zero.

How to send us your records

The easiest way is to reply to the audit email from our office with your documents attached. You can also:

  • Email them to support@karstensfinancial.com with your business name in the subject line
  • Call us at 855-657-8400 and we will walk through the audit form with you over the phone
  • Reply to our text message if a quick answer is all the auditor needs (for example, confirming there were no subcontractors)

Please do not send Social Security numbers or bank details; the auditor does not need them. If a carrier’s audit form asks for something you are not comfortable sending, call us first.

Common questions

I had no employees this year. Do I still have to do the audit?

Yes. Tell the auditor there was no payroll and send the 941s or a short statement saying so. A completed audit showing zero payroll usually produces a refund down to the policy minimum; an ignored one gets estimated.

Does overtime count?

Only the straight-time portion. The extra half (the “premium” part of time-and-a-half) is excluded in most states, but only if your payroll records show overtime separately. That is why we ask for it broken out.

Are owners and officers counted?

It depends on your entity type, your state, and whether an inclusion or exclusion form was filed with the policy. Included owners are charged at a state-set minimum and maximum payroll rather than their actual pay. We confirm what your policy says before the auditor applies it.

The audit says I owe money. Can I dispute it?

Yes, within the carrier’s dispute window (often 30 days from the audit invoice). Send us the audit worksheet and we will compare it with your records. Errors in class codes, excluded pay and subcontractor charges are common and are corrected when documented.

How do I avoid a big bill next year?

Tell us when you hire, add a location or take on a new kind of work, and we will adjust the estimate mid-term. Keep overtime separate in payroll, and collect a certificate of insurance from every subcontractor before they start.